Using “positive punishment” (pain) to stop behavior, Does stop the behavior (in the moment.) And THE HUMAN is Reinforced by Seeing the behavior stop. If punishment were a permanent solution you would only get hurt once and Never do it again, but we all know too well that that isn’t the way behavior works. The very need to continue the use of or threat of pain testifies to it’s lack. Changing the dogs attitude about the trigger gives permanent life long results.
Click Link for information regarding dog calming signals